Eligible by Curtis Sittenfeld – review

Published by Borough Press

Publication date – 21 April 2016

Source – gift review copy


“The Bennet sisters have been summoned from New York City.

Liz and Jane are good daughters. They’ve come home to suburban Cincinnati to get their mother to stop feeding their father steak as he recovers from heart surgery, to tidy up the crumbling Tudor-style family home, and to wrench their three sisters from their various states of arrested development.

Once they are under the same roof, old patterns return fast. Soon enough they are being berated for their single status, their only respite the early morning runs they escape on together. For two successful women in their late thirties, it really is too much to bear. That is, until the Lucas family’s BBQ throws them in the way of some eligible single men . . .

Chip Bingley is not only a charming doctor, he’s a reality TV star too. But Chip’s friend, haughty neurosurgeon Fitzwilliam Darcy, can barely stomach Cincinnati or its inhabitants. Jane is entranced by Chip; Liz, sceptical of Darcy. As Liz is consumed by her father’s mounting medical bills, her wayward sisters and Cousin Willie trying to stick his tongue down her throat, it isn’t only the local chilli that will leave a bad aftertaste.

But where there are hearts that beat and mothers that push, the mysterious course of love will resolve itself in the most entertaining and unlikely of ways. And from the hand of Curtis Sittenfeld, Pride & Prejudice is catapulted into our modern world singing out with hilarity and truth.”

Mr Bennet has had a heart attack so Lizzy and her elder sister Jane return to the family home in Cincinnati. There she finds her younger sisters caught up in a Crossfit health craze, but doing little to provide for themselves. Her middle sister Mary is doing yet another degree, and again failing to work in the process. As for Lizzy’s mother, it would appear she is busy trying to match make Jane with Chip Bingley, Doctor and star of Eligible, a reality TV series. But with Chip comes his best friend Darcy. A man Lizzy can’t help but loathe….

Eligible is the latest instalment in Borough Press’ The Austen Project, which sees each of Jane Austen’s novels reimagined in the modern day by a litany of well known and well respected novelists. This time it’s the turn of Pride and Prejudice which has emerged as Eligible under the pen of Curtis Sittenfeld.

Lots of things are different in the novel. Lizzy and Jane are older and absent from the family home, though both still have their rent paid for by Mr Bennet. Lady Catherine De Bourgh for example is now a rather pleasant aged feminist, rather than the snobby harridan in the original. George Wickham has a different name and role in the story and there are new characters, for example Ham, who take over pivotal roles in the narrative. There are some things that haven’t changed. The younger Bennet sisters are highly annoying, spoilt and often down-right rude. Mrs Bennet is still highly strung, but now exhibits not so latent racist, bigoted views with undercurrents of anti-Semitism and a side helping of shopping addiction. She is still obsessed with getting her daughters married off. Mr Bennet is still slightly absent and amuses himself with the foibles of his wife and children, and seemingly abdicates responsibility for finances to the detriment of the family.

I had issues with the book. I was unsure at first if I was enjoying it. I found Lizzy to be annoying, more so than in Pride and Prejudice (in which she tends to be more sanctimonious than annoying) for example and Willie Collins not nearly as sycophantic and obsequious as the original Mr Collins and therefore a little harder to dislike and I did spend some time wondering how the story was going to retain the key points of the original when it appeared to be deviating.  Despite being aware of how the story would play out the book seems to draw you in, compelling you to read despite being aware of the origins of the story and making the inevitable comparisons. I read 300 pages in one evening (don’t be phased by its 510 pages for it is surprisingly easy to read), so drawn in by the story was I, helped by the short chapters that lend themselves to the justification of ‘just one more…’ I realised that I was enjoying the novel, wrapped up in the modern day lives of the Bennets of Cincinnati. It was interesting to see how Curtis Sittenfeld would make all the storyline of Pride and Prejudice fit into the modern day and the scenario she had opened with. It is a novel that doesn’t take itself too seriously and it would appear that the author had fun imagining the Bennets in the 21st Century.

There are inevitably going to be comparisons with the original. Pride and Prejudice is a classic for many reasons. It was an insight into the social norms and idiosyncrasies of the time, of societal standings and ridiculing the prejudices and norms of the time. In some instances Eligible does the same, dealing as it does racial and sexual issues, with the invasion of reality TV, of the trashy television, the desire for publicity and the media’s intrusion into our daily lives. It is done perhaps with a tongue more firmly in cheek and a little more modern comedy, though Jane Austen was not adverse to wit in her novels.

This is my first encounter with Curtis Sittenfeld’s novels. I’m now keen to see what her other novels contain.



11 Comments Add yours

  1. I’ve been toying with the idea of reading this. I enjoyed both Sisterland and American Wife but I’m not keen on ‘tribute’ novels. You seem to have been won over by it in the end, Janet. One for the easy reading pile?


    1. janetemson says:

      I’d say its one for the easy reading pile Susan, that’s just what it is. It was lovely to read a book and just enjoy it, realising I didn’t have to have expectations about it, or that it mattered one way or the other that any expectations were met. It’s a fun way to spend a few hours 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thanks, Janet. A slipping the brain into neutral kind of read then!


  2. Kate W says:

    I have this in the TBR pile and have been unsure – on the one hand, ‘if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’. On the other, I reckon I’m in safe hands with Sittenfeld – she’s a talented and engaging writer.

    Good to know that the 510 pages are of the ‘light’ variety!


    1. janetemson says:

      I was put off by the length but some chapters are short, occasionally just a paragraph, so it seems easy to justify a couple more, and soon I was flying through it 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  3. American wife was a great book so image give this a try,despite having all the same reservations you had at the outset. Thanks fir an informative review.


    1. janetemson says:

      I’ve not read any of her other books so I’ll be interested to see how she is with ‘original’ storylines. Let me know if you enjoy Eligible if you read it 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Joanne says:

    I really enjoyed this. I loved working out the similarities and differences between this and the original. My favourite update so far has been Sense & Sensibility.


    1. janetemson says:

      I think that’s part of the fun with novels like these, seeing how they can translate to modern day when a lot of the social norms that Austen comments on have disappeared today (or are at least drastically altered). I liked S&S too and Northanger Abbey was good. I’ve not read Emma. I’ll be interested to see how the next authors handle Mansfield Park and Persuasion, particularly Persuasion as it’s my favourite novel 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.